
A water heater heating element is the metal rod that turns electricity into heat inside an electric tank water heater. Most electric tanks have two, an upper and a lower. When one fails, you usually notice lukewarm water or none at all. You can test each element with a multimeter once power is off at the breaker, and replacing one is a manageable job for a careful homeowner who follows the steps below.
Why a water heater heating element fails
An element is a resistance heater sitting directly in the water, so it fails in a few predictable ways. The sheath can burn through, the internal wire can break, or the element can short to the metal tank. Mineral scale from hard water can coat the element and cause it to overheat in spots, and that heat shortens its life.
Running the element with the tank empty or with the element uncovered is one of the fastest ways to destroy it. This is covered in more detail below.
Upper and lower elements explained
Most electric tanks have an upper element near the top of the tank and a lower element near the bottom. Each element has its own thermostat, and the two are wired so they do not run at the same time. In most designs, the upper element heats the top of the tank first, and the lower element takes over to heat the bottom once the upper thermostat is satisfied.
This matters for troubleshooting. If hot water runs out quickly or stays lukewarm, the failed element is often the one that heats the part of the tank you are drawing from. Check the wiring diagram on the access panel cover to confirm which element does what on your unit.
Upper element symptoms
A bad upper element often leaves you with hot water for a short time, then lukewarm water, because the lower element can only heat part of the tank. Showers may run warm at first and then cool quickly.
Lower element symptoms
A bad lower element can leave you with plenty of hot water at the top of the tank but little usable heat after a few uses. Hot water may seem to disappear faster than expected.
Symptoms of a failed element
Look for these signs before you pull the access panels:
- Water that is lukewarm or never reaches the temperature you set.
- Hot water that runs out sooner than it used to.
- No hot water at all, with the cold supply working normally.
- A breaker that trips when the water heater is running.
- Rumbling or popping sounds, which can come from sediment rather than the element, so check both.
Several of these symptoms also come from a bad thermostat, a blown fuse, a tripped high-temperature limit, or sediment buildup. Test the element before you assume it is the cause.
Safety first
Turn off the breaker that feeds the water heater, then confirm power is off with a voltage tester at the element terminals. Do not rely on the switch on the unit or on the thermostat setting. Electric elements run on high voltage, and a shock can cause serious injury. If the breaker panel, wiring, or terminals look scorched, stop and call a professional.
Tools you need
- A digital multimeter that can measure resistance (ohms) and check continuity
- A voltage tester to confirm the power is off
- An element wrench or a socket that fits the element, typically a large socket with a long handle
- A screwdriver for the access panels and terminal screws
- A flashlight, a phone camera, and masking tape with a marker for labeling wires
- A bucket or hose to drain the tank before replacement
How to test a water heater element with a multimeter
Testing takes about as long as opening the panels, and it tells you whether the element itself is the problem. Work through the steps in order.
- Turn off the breaker and confirm power is off with your voltage tester at the element terminals.
- Remove the insulation cover and the plastic access panel over the element you are testing. Photograph the wiring before you disconnect anything.
- Label and disconnect the two wires from the element terminals. Keep the labels with the wires so you can reconnect them correctly.
- Set the multimeter to resistance (ohms) and touch one probe to each terminal of the element. A reading in ohms means the internal circuit is complete.
- Use the continuity setting if your meter has one. A beep means a closed path. No beep means the circuit is open.
- Test each terminal against the metal of the element flange or tank using the resistance setting. Any reading other than an open circuit means current is leaking to ground, and the element should be replaced.
- Compare the resistance to the expected value. Read the wattage and voltage printed on the element, then calculate the expected resistance as the voltage squared divided by the wattage. A reading close to that figure means the element is likely good.
Interpreting your readings
- Open circuit (the meter shows OL or infinite resistance, with no beep): the element is burned out and needs replacement.
- Reading near zero ohms: the element is shorted internally and needs replacement.
- Reading to ground: the sheath is failing and the element should be replaced.
- Reading close to the calculated value, with no reading to ground: the element is probably good. Check the thermostat and the high-temperature limit next.
A reading that falls between these cases can be hard to call. If you are unsure, replace the element or ask a professional to test it on the unit.
Set the thermostat to a safe temperature
After you restore power and the tank heats, set the thermostat with scalding in mind. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, 120°F is a temperature considered safe for most of the population. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) recommends setting water heaters to 120°F and notes that third-degree burns can occur after about 5 minutes at that temperature. The DOE says people with a compromised immune system or chronic respiratory disease may want to keep the setting at 140°F.
Why dry-firing an element destroys it
Dry-firing means energizing an element that is not fully covered by water. The element has no water to carry heat away, so it overheats and the sheath or internal wire can fail quickly. A tank that has been drained for repairs, or one that has run out of water after a leak, is the usual setup for this damage.
Always confirm the tank is full before you restore power. Open a hot tap somewhere in the house and let the air purge from the lines before you turn the breaker back on. Keep the breaker off while the tank is empty, even if you think the job is nearly finished.
How to replace a water heater element
Replacing a single element is a repair most homeowners can handle if they are comfortable with wiring and draining the tank. The steps below give you the overall sequence. Your unit's manual or the element's packaging may add specific instructions.
- Turn off the breaker and verify power is off at the element terminals.
- Shut off the cold water supply to the tank.
- Drain the tank to a level below the element you are replacing. Attach a hose to the drain valve and run it to a floor drain or outside. Open a hot tap to let air in and speed up draining.
- Remove the access panel and insulation, then disconnect and label the wires.
- Unscrew the old element with the element wrench. Expect some resistance from scale. Keep the wrench square to the element so you do not damage the flange.
- Clean the mounting surface around the opening so the new gasket seals flat.
- Install the new element with its gasket. Tighten it to the snug fit described in the instructions, without overtightening.
- Reconnect the wires to the matching terminals and replace the insulation and panel.
- Refill the tank. Open a hot tap until water flows steadily without sputtering, then close it.
- Check for leaks at the element flange before you restore power. Recheck after the tank has been running for a while.
- Restore power at the breaker and confirm the water heats as expected.
Do not cap, plug, or remove the temperature and pressure relief valve during any of these steps. It is a safety device and must stay in working condition. Relief valve discharge piping is governed by the International Plumbing Code and International Residential Code, but the exact requirements vary by jurisdiction, so check with your local building department before you change that piping.
When to call a professional
Call a professional if the breaker trips again after a new element is installed, if you see burned or discolored wiring, if the tank itself is leaking, or if you are not comfortable working with the wiring. Replacing the whole unit may make more sense than repairing an element on an old tank. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, most storage water heaters last 10 to 15 years.
If you hire someone, get at least two written quotes. Check the contractor's license with the state licensing board where licensing applies. Ask whether the job requires a permit, who pulls it, and whether the quote includes haul-away of the old element or tank, any code upgrades, and warranty registration. Your local building department can tell you which permits apply in your area.
How to prevent element failure
- Keep the thermostat at a safe setting. Lower settings reduce the work the elements do and reduce scalding risk.
- Flush sediment periodically following the manufacturer's instructions, especially if your water is hard. Scale buildup on the element causes uneven heating.
- Keep the tank full. Address leaks right away so the elements are never exposed.
- Check the relief valve for drips or corrosion, and never plug it.
- Keep combustibles away from the water heater and its surrounding area, and keep the area clear for service access.
Frequently asked questions
Can I test a water heater element without removing it?
Yes, in many cases. With the breaker off and the wires disconnected, you can test the element's resistance and check for a reading to ground while it is still installed. Removing the element gives you a clearer view of its condition and lets you inspect the sheath for scale or damage, but it is not always required for a basic test.
How do I know if my upper or lower element is bad?
Test each element separately with the multimeter. An open circuit or a reading to ground points to a failed element. Symptoms also help: hot water that runs out quickly often points to the lower element, while lukewarm water at the tap can point to the upper element. Confirm with the test before buying parts.
Should I replace both elements at the same time?
Many people replace both if one has failed and the tank is several years old, since the other element may be near the end of its life. If the other element tests well and the tank is in good shape, you can replace just the failed one. Replacing both at once also means you only drain and refill the tank once.
What happens if I turn the water heater on with the tank empty?
Turning on an element with no water covering it can overheat and burn out the element quickly. Always confirm the tank is full before restoring power. If you drained the tank for service, open a hot tap and let air clear from the lines before turning the breaker back on.
Is it safe to replace a water heater element myself?
It can be, if you are comfortable working with high-voltage wiring and draining a tank, and you verify the power is off before touching any terminals. If you are unsure about any step, or if the wiring looks damaged, hire a professional. Check your local building department to find out whether a permit is required for the work.
Why does my hot water still feel weak after replacing the element?
Check the thermostat settings, the high-temperature limit, and the wiring connections first. Sediment in the bottom of the tank can also reduce how much hot water you get. If the problem continues after the element is confirmed good and the tank has been flushed, have the thermostats tested by a professional.